Pages

Showing posts with label student writing. Show all posts
Showing posts with label student writing. Show all posts

Saturday, April 5, 2014

Designer Blends

I have spent two years designing, redesigning, and improving my blend. I have spent an inordinate amount of time making and editing lecture videos, rewriting lessons for asynchronous online days, modifying them for synchronous AdobeConnect days, and scrapping both lessons at the last minute to teach the lesson face-to-face. I have surveyed my students extensively, exhausted my TAs, and pushed myself to the breaking point in getting this blend right--all while simultaneously rewriting my syllabus each semester to incorporate more lessons on information and digital literacy and transform many traditional assignments into digital ones.

From day one, my mission has been not just to maintain but to strengthen the productive, interactive community of learners that is paramount to my teaching. I believe that deep learning is rooted in Dewey's collaborative constructivism: we learn through doing, with each other. Critical inquiry and deep learning is predicated on a safe, supportive learning environment. As such, "going blended" has meant taking advantage of synchronous activities to foster exploration and experimentation in Googledocs and face-to-face classes and asynchronous activities to foster reflection in discussion boards and Voicethreads. My students are free writing, experimenting, drafting, revising, editing, and polishing work that is significantly better at the end of the semester than it is at the beginning. They are collaborating with each other more comfortably. They are writing more on the discussion boards than they ever could speak in class. We know each other better than we did even in my highly participatory, horseshoed-desked, discussion-based traditional classrooms.

The rewards can be seen through my students' writing and self-awareness. If writing is thinking on the page, and my job is to help students think critically about themselves as learners and writers, then my students need to be writing more. They are: My students produce an average of 70 pages of writing every semester, 30 of which are revised and polished. Even in my early semesters teaching blended, my students were making greater improvements in their writing than my students had in my traditional classes. They are reflecting on their digital literacy and media addictions, their research skills, and how well (or not) their high school teachers prepared them for college writing and research. They are providing more and better feedback to each other because they have more time to write careful feedback online. Plus, the online feedback is written, so students can't forget what their peers have said. They just need to go back and look.


If blended learning is seen as a method to save time and resources and increase convenience, then it's never going to gain acceptance among educators, especially compositionists. This does not bode well, for more and more college courses are being offered as blended/ hybrid every year. Resistance from compositionists is warranted if the format is pedagogically unsound, but done well, the format is not simply pedagogically sound: it's pedagogically obvious. Students are writing more, interacting more, and reflecting more. They are doing this by writing more. The net result is that my blended students are making incredible progress in fifteen short weeks, progress that I never would have thought possible three years ago. As a writing teacher, I will take nearly any risk if there's a possibility that it will help my students become better writers. The risks are high. The rewards are real.

Saturday, March 8, 2014

An Apology and a Modest Defense

I have an apology to make to all English teachers and English majors out there:

I did not mean to imply that there's something intrinsically wrong with being an English major, or that there's something wrong with the discipline. English majors and scholars are vital both in and out of the academy.

When I tweeted "Encouraging Ss to become ENGL majors is arguably more unethical than encouraging them to stay in college" the other night, I was doing two things: 

  1. contributing to the "ethical" theme that was dominant in this week's chat and
  2. making a larger argument about our role as writing teachers.

For context, the theme of this week's chat was FYC and retention. The initial question at the top of the hour was:

"So why does FYC have such a big impact on students' retention?" followed shortly by 
"Is it your responsibility as a professor to try to keep students in college?"

Here are some of the responses:

I had this amazing student one year who told me he hated college, it wasn't challenging, and he wanted to leave... I didn't know what to tell him about staying in school 

It's certainly not my job to keep them in college no matter what. That's a question that can stray into ethical areas. 

He was so smart and engaged. I thought he would do well in school. But yeah, ethically, I didn't know what to say 

Did you tell him there's nothing wrong with leaving? Do we have to sell education? 

 I tried to just listen and offer my best advice 

Pushing is one thing. Helping Ss think through their options and consequences is valuable, though. 

I agree. I am very uncomfortable with selling the university. I'd rather spend my time helping them analyze it! 

Absolutely, it is not our job to keep students from leaving, but there are ways we can help. 

At my cc, I sometimes encounter Ss who aren't confident about being in college or have been told outright they won't succeed...so they may benefit from retention-focused FYC in multiple ways.... 

because "college isn't for everyone" still implies failure on the student's part. 

 yes, exactly! not the message I want to send 

Do you talk about conversion of FYC students to English majors are part of your retention conversation? 

We do. It is now in the syllabus and orientation to encourage good writers to become ENGL majors 

Encourage students to become ENGL majors? Why?

Encouraging Ss to become ENGL majors is arguably more unethical than encouraging them to stay in college 

My point here is that ethically, encouraging students to stay in college is one thing. Encouraging them to become English majors (or any major, for that matter) is a completely different story. 

We FYC teachers find ourselves in the position of advising students all the time--or, rather, students come to us far more than they do most other professors, because they usually know us better. The ethics of this are discussed regularly--as they should be. We're not academic advisors. We're not counselors. We're writing teachers. Still, students come to us for advice, and we all make our own decisions about what is and is not appropriate.

I've had the "should I stay in school" conversation several times. I listen. I nod sympathetically. I try to shift the focus to completing my course successfully.  Last year, I had a student who had no interest in being in school at all and was here because her mother wanted her to have at least a year of college under her belt. "You're almost halfway there," I offered. "My advice to you is to do the best you can so that if you choose to return at some point down the road, you'll at least have a couple of classes on your transcript that you won't have to repeat."

I think this is sound advice. But converting FYC students to English majors? No. Here's why:

The majority of my students have declared, even as first-semester freshmen. I do not think it is appropriate to impose my discipline on my biochem or aerospace engineering or finance or dance majors. As for the undeclared: I tell them to take everything. I encourage them to think in terms of courses, not majors. A course is a semester-long decision. A major is a multi-year decision with direct consequences on their graduate and/ or professional careers. Again, I'm not an advisor.

Moreover, I don't endorse the idea that good writers should be English majors. Just because you're a good writer doesn't mean that you should be an English major. Rather, it means that you are well-positioned to go further in your chosen field because you know how to think critically and communicate your ideas effectively. That's what we need. We need good writers in all disciplines, and we need to help students understand that this "English" class is not an "English" class at all--it's a life skills class. We focus on critical thinking, rhetorical analysis, information literacy, efficient research skills, and effective argumentation. These skills are not the sole purview of English departments. We teach these skills so that our students can succeed in all of their other courses.

I don't want to keep all of the good writers. I want to send them out to all of the other departments on campus. I want the engineering and environmental studies majors to write as well as the English majors. I want our students to research what they're passionate about and be able to contribute to their fields without having a panic attack when faced with a ten-page writing assignment and running down the hall to find an "English major" to help them write their papers.

That's where I'm coming from.

I hope that this helps. I'm sorry if my words stung; I didn't mean to offend. As always, I welcome your comments.




Tuesday, March 4, 2014

Going Public

As we're in the final stretch of Argument as Inquiry, I'm looking ahead to the rest of the semester. It's all new.

This semester, my students are going public. I've moved the "final paper," the academic position paper, from the last week to week 11. I'm now calling it the "academic argument" to distinguish it from the new project: "the public argument."

My students are conducting quality academic research that doesn't go anywhere. Their "academic audience" is a false construct (they're not *really* going to publish in the Journal of Social Psychology as freshman college students), and most of what they write in my class is "just for English."

I hate that, as do many in my field. So, I'm handling this by having them publish their research findings online. Their last "paper" will be targeted to the public, to the blogosphere and twitterverse. I've made a class twitter (@LyraBL101) and asked all of my students to make new Twitter accounts for themselves and follow us at #Lyra101. They're to follow any author or source that they use in their research and later, will tweet at those authors, telling them that they're using their work in their papers. When they publish their work online--on Blogger, Weebly, or Wix--they're going to tweet about it, tell people on Facebook and Tumblr (neither of which I go near--that's their world, not mine), and, I hope, get people to comment on their work. 

Students will repurpose their papers and small assignments from earlier in the semester for a public audience. They might turn some of their earlier work into a series of blog posts, or keep the larger papers as stand-alone arguments but cut them in half, from 1500 to 750 words. 

I theme my class around media, technology, and education, so students research something that nominally is related to one of those fields. I try to group students together by topic for peer review groups. Those groups will stick together for this last project.  I want them to build these websites in groups, and then each of them will have a portal or something to their individual research. 

I don't think it's reasonable to have each student build his or her own website. A simple blogger, fine. But I want more than that. I want them to have a website that can house a Twitter feed, a blog, a full paper, an annotated bibliography with hyperlinks, etc. I think that this needs to be a group effort. Some students will do it easily; others will be completely intimidated. So, building this website as a group seems like the way to go.

The sticky area is privacy. I've asked students to make new Twitter accounts specifically for this class so that they keep their private and professional worlds separate. I know that several other professors require students to use Twitter, so this won't be the last time they're asked to make a "professional student" account. I've asked students to use a name that I will recognize, but it doesn't need to be their full name--they can just use "Stan ENGL" as their full name for this assignment. While part of my objectives are to teach them digital literacy skills and how to conduct oneself online in a professional manner, I still want to protect them. They may not want their employer in five years (or five months) to read their college papers.

I'm walking an interesting line between encouraging my students to publish their work online so that their research actually matters to someone other than me and wanting to protect them from their "future" selves. I'm asking them to follow people on Twitter and tweet about their research. My students need to be "real people," but they don't need to be identifiable to the point where their Twitter and Weebly for this class is easily linked to their personal Twitter or Facebook. It's a Brave New World in higher ed and literacy studies...

Monday, March 3, 2014

7 Highly Effective Habits of Teachers Who Hold Classes on Snow Days

I just held synchronous classes in AdobeConnect on a snow day.

To explain this, I'm going to use this nice infographic I found from dailyedventures.com:



1. They Always Start with the Why
Why did I do this? Simple: it was peer review day. It's the only day they had to go over their drafts with each other before submitting the final in a week. Peer review is far too important to skip, and making margin comments on drafts--even thorough comments--is only part of the process. Being able to actually talk to each other is critical. So I did it.

2. They are malleable and can easily adapt

I had seen this coming by about 48 hours. I knew I wanted to go online--I had to. There's no room in the syllabus to lose a day. I scoured university policies and legal notices, making sure I wasn't doing anything illegal. I wasn't--there isn't a policy that explicitly addresses online classes at all, let alone one about holding one when the campus is closed.

Even so, holding peer review online is tricky. AdobeConnect is okay, but TAs can't move themselves in and out of breakout rooms. That's a big problem. In the past, I've plucked a TA out of a group--mid-sentence--and dropped her into a new group. It's a mess.

So how did I adapt this time? By somehow convincing six former TAs to come in and help. I have no idea how I did this--I didn't beg or sound desperate; I just asked--but somehow they all popped in for one of the classes. I had enough TAs for one to be in each group for all three sections. It was brilliant.

3. They embrace change 

Thanks to our class Twitter that I launched this week (@LyraBL101), I was able to tweet about this possibility, and then decision, all weekend. With the right tools and attitude, anything is possible!

4. They share, share, and then share some more

See #3. And this blog. Follow me @lyrahilliard. Add comments on this post. Ask me anything!

5. They think win-win-win

I wanted today to be fun--as fun as it could be, anyway. Had we been in class, I would have brought cookies in; I always do that for the first review. I obviously couldn't do that today, but I brought in special guests! Courtney gave a great Writing Center overview by sharing her screen with us and showing us the website. And then students had 40 minutes with a TA (or me) and their peers. I think students appreciated it. I hope so. I know that some had connectivity problems, and my own connection cut out in my first class. In my last class, I accidentally rearranged all of the groups, which was an epic disaster. But we survived (see #2).

6. They are extremely thorough and think two steps ahead

I had already called this on Saturday. I knew campus would be closed. If I hadn't had yesterday to plan, I wouldn't have thought to ask former TAs to help, and then none of this could have happened. We held a brief Google Hangout last night, TAs sent out an announcement, I got into AdobeConnect early this morning to test settings...it all worked. It all totally worked.

7. They actively care

Believe me, I wouldn't have minded a day off! But there was no way. This wasn't a "theory" class; it was a "practice" class: hands on, working with the writing class. Students can't lose this class--that's not fair. Or right. I asked my TAs what they thought--and what they thought students would think. "You should mention that it's optional," one said. "No--you shouldn't mention that it's optional--then no one will come." "I don't think anyone will come, anyway." "Yeah but it's peer review. They should understand that it's important." "Yeah but will they?"

Apparently, they did. About 75% of each class showed up. Not bad for a snow day.

After the last class, I asked D if he thought it worked. "You made the right call," he said.

What would you have done? Would you hold class online on a snow day?




Friday, February 7, 2014

Epiphanic Fridays: Five Powerful Reasons to Respond to Your Students' Initial Discussion Board Posts

I just finished responding to the "Introductions and Writing Habits" Discussion Board for one of my three sections. It's time-consuming, yes, but invaluable. Here's why:

Value #1: My students deserve to be seen. My TAs respond to each student, and students respond to each other, but students really need to hear from me, too (which I haven't always done in the past). I teach blended sections, so students only see me in a brick and mortar classroom once a week. The prompt this semester enabled me to do a lot:

The purpose of this discussion board is to get to know each other better, to reflect on your experiences with writing and learning, and to discuss your goals for this course.
What kinds of writing do you do the most? What do you enjoy the most? The least? What writing habits have worked well for you in the past that you can continue to employ this semester? What difficulties with writing (think broad--this can also include researching, studying, time management, etc.) would you like to overcome? What can we (your classmates, the TA, and Lyra) do that would help you meet your goals this semester?
Primary posts (due Wednesday by midnight): write a 200-250 word post introducing yourself to the class. Include the following:
  • The things you shared about yourself in class (name, where you’re from, etc.)
  • A reflection about your writing experiences (based on the questions above).
  • A picture of yourself: How to add a picture to your Canvas profile

Secondary posts (due by class on Monday): Respond to the posts of two of your classmates, identifying things you share in common, if applicable, and offering feedback and strategies for how each classmate could meet his or her semester goals.

(Basic takeaways: we all struggle with writing and students are resources for each other)

Value #2: I know my students much better than I usually do this early in the semester. Reading and responding to their writing habits and challenges has enabled me to see who likes/ doesn't like analysis and research, who outlines, who prefers creative writing, who struggles with time management and distractions (don't we all!), and so forth. As evidence: I can identify at least one thing about most of my students in my first two sections, but don't feel as though I know anyone in my third section yet. Why? Because I haven't started responding to their Intro posts.

Value #3: Students get to know me. The more curious students will likely read more than one of my responses (especially after this weekend's announcement, in which I will encourage them to do so). Throughout the nineteen responses, I covered things like where I've lived, where I've traveled, what I like to write, and especially how I approach the writing and research process. Rumor and research has it that students appreciate seeing their teachers as human beings.

Value #4 (HUGE): Students get a very good sense of exactly what we're going to do this semester. If anyone reads through all of my responses, they will:
  • know what the first paper is all about,
  • understand why we're starting with summary and analysis and how that leads to the first paper,
  • understand why I'm asking them to respond to each other's posts, 
  • understand the difference between "looking for" something specific in a text (e.g. rhetorical context) and responding to one of my questions versus responding to the actual ideas (such, such a good distinction to make...) and how that relates to the first paper, 
  • know that they're going to start researching their semester project next week,
  • know that we will spend a LOT of time on research strategies and tips (which they all want),
  • know that I am militant about concision and that I will help them with that,
  • know that I help them with time management by setting multiple due dates for partial drafts and full drafts,
  • know that they have a full week to revise their papers after the in-class draft workshops,
  • know that they will write different kinds of arguments for different audiences, both academic and public (online), and
  • know that I care deeply about what we do in this course and about making sure they learn what they need to learn to succeed in the rest of their college classes. More than once I mentioned that I revamp the syllabus and many assignments every semester, something I hope students understand works out quite well in their favor.
That's a lot of good information. Now, most of that is written in the syllabus and the "General Course Overview and FAQs" page on Canvas, our LMS, but I'd wager a bet that students will get more out of my responses here than whatever they skimmed (or didn't) last week. They theoretically read four or five syallabi last week. Reinforcing several concepts here in the DB, after they've gotten to know me and the class for a couple of weeks, will likely make a lot of my information stick.

Value #5 (GINORMOUS): I just solved one of the biggest mysteries of teaching writing.

I've been helping students with writer's block for seven years. I discuss my process--just sit down to write--and explain how that leads to figuring out what I think (Didion). Classic Elbow, Murray, Lamott--everyone. Puke drafts. 

That's good advice--it's helped a lot of students. But after reading and responding to at least ten students who struggle with "just getting started" and "staring at the screen forever," reminding a couple of students about what they learned in Graff and Birkenstein last week (Burke/ Entering a Conversation), and then reading one student's post about what his wife (an attorney) recommends (start with your research notes), it came to me: 

People, it's not about you. It is never about you. It's not about you, a blank screen, and your ideas.

You're writing to figure out what you think (yes) about other people's ideas. 

Okay, duh--I talk about this all the time in class. But what I say in class probably isn't in students' minds when they sit down to draft. 

Epiphany and Praxis:

Students, when you open up a new document for your papers, this is what you're going to do: you're going to copy your one-sentence summaries of all of the sources on your working bibliographies and paste them directly into the document. That's your starting place. You're going to look at these six ideas and then you're going to start your puke draft. Just. Write. Responses. To. These. Six. Ideas.

Cue forwarding ideas and synthesizing sources. Cue puke draft that doesn't feel as terrifyingly unorganized as a creative writer's puke draft.

After seven years, I just came to this now?? Yeah, yeah. The big takeaway that I will discuss on Monday with this class: I didn't get here until I had responded to everyone. It came to me within thirty minutes of getting up and doing something else. It was through responding ten times about the writing and research process, and reading the advice given to one of my students--that it all clicked. And that's what I mean by writing in order to figure out what you think. 

I'm wicked excited about this! Maybe not revelatory to anyone else, but I know that some students simply can't just write cold, no matter what I say about writing just for your own eyes first (Stephen King), or putting a manilla folder over the screen so that you aren't staring at your own words, or whatever--this doesn't work for every student. I suspect this strategy will. Staring at the one-sentence summaries of arguments you're about to engage with is a concrete reminder that as a writer, you are never alone. You are always writing in response to someone else's ideas, just like I'm doing right now. You're not "defending" your own argument--you're developing it based on what you've learned. Pasting the one-sentence summaries on the page will reinforce this core concept--it will literally put the "They Say/ I Say" right there in front of them. 

Brilliant. 

Name one other exercise in which you can do all of the above without writing responses to every student that every person in class can see. I'd love to know what you do!

Tuesday, February 4, 2014

Timing Lesson Plans

I never leave enough time in my lesson plans. Like ever.

It's not for lack of planning: I write them all out--to the time. I rewrite all of my lesson plans, even lessons that I know are successful. So how did I run out of time yesterday?

Okay, this is what happened: I didn't have time to go over the one-sentence summaries from last Wednesday, so I tried to put them into yesterday's lesson plan, which really didn't work. Observe:

:00 Quiz
:05 One-Sentence Summaries from last week
:15 Aims/ Methods/ Materials
:20 Group Summaries: Module 2 → “How to Write a Summary”
:45-50: One-sentence  summaries w/ diff sent. struct.
:00-05: PCA Wed (asynch/ Voicethread)

Stop laughing.

Okay, the quiz actually was just five minutes. Super easy, most true/ false or multiple choice, like what's the TA's name, where is my office (one of the options was Florida), and then some fairly simple concept questions (like rhetorical context, which actually most students did not get, despite the fact that I went over it last Wednesday and it was in the WA homework. I honestly don't know why so many students missed that one--anyone? Insight/ tips?)

The one-sentence summaries: I did go over them in my first class, which of course took ten minutes, not five. Reinforced the precise verbs, putting the author as the grammatical subject, and that the information in the one-sentence version needs to include rhetorical context and authorial intent/ message. This is *your* thesis statement about the text. This is also...

...The "Aims" in Joseph Harris's Aims/ Methods/ Materials. Methods and Materials are basically the construction and the tools (Methods --> how the author builds the text; Materials --> with what (tools, or evidence). Methods and materials are what gets included in a paragraph summary.

That went well in my first class...except that it of course took twenty-five minutes, not fifteen. That said, packing sentence structure, precise verbs, does/ says, and aims/ methods/ materials in twenty-five minutes isn't half bad. I just don't know why I thought I could do it in fifteen.

So, writing a group summary takes forty minutes, not thirty. And I actually knew this--I remember this from last semester (and the one before, for that matter). So, in my second and third classes, I cut the one-sentence summaries from last week, a choice I don't like because I wasn't able to integrate this class as tightly with the last one--and because that opening fifteen minutes really was helpful in my first class. So, the net result is that my first class was stressed that they didn't have enough time to finish their summaries (they finished them by midnight) and my second two classes didn't get to see me discuss their sentences and how that relates to aims/ methods/ materials.

Moreover--and this is arguably the biggest fallout--cutting into those last fifteen minutes means that I run out of time for "context" notes, like explaining why we're doing what we're doing, how this relates to what we did last week/ what we will do next week. I also lose really key "housekeeping" notes, like explaining that my TAs and I work as a team, my TA "office lounge," and things like class notes, which I haven't yet talked about at all!

So: I'm writing Monday's lesson plan already and need to save myself 20 minutes to go over all the auxiliary details that I haven't had time to yet. Maybe 25. That will work--it's the first day after the add/ drop period ends, so Monday's students will officially have committed themselves to the class.

I might post Monday's lesson plan here first for C and R to comment on, as they've both TAd twice and know all too well the gap between my ambition and what is realistic in the classroom.

So, tomorrow is our first asynchronous day. Student's are watching K's Summary Video and then doing a Voicethread in which they're responding to each other's group summaries from yesterday. The Voicethread doesn't explicitly incorporate the Summary video, unfortunately (that's always the ideal with video lectures--students need to do something with them to make them relevant), but it's set up pretty well. My TAs are doing a "demo" slide so that after the first slides where I explain how Voicethread works, students can see a slide in action. I'm excited for this one--I think it will be cool for students to hear each other comment on each other's summaries instead of just writing about them in a discussion board, as they have in the past. This makes it more real.

I still want to do something with those sentences...I don't know what. Put them all somewhere and have students revise them? Possibly. Where--a Discussion Board (meh). A Googledoc? Maybe. I could do that sentence structure thing, i.e., revise this twice, one by opening with these two words ("In the...") and the other with ("Writing for..."). These are LAST week's one-sentence summaries (all of Gabriel), so in theory, they know more now about good one-sentence summaries.

Yeah....but then they'll all be exactly the same. They should really do them with the new articles. Maybe it can be in two parts: revise someone else's sentences in two ways, and then revise your group's Gabriel sentence from last week in two ways.

Hm. I might like this. This saves me from having to beat this into the ground next Monday, and gets rid of that holdover item from last Wednesday.

Okay. That's what I'll do then. Video + Voicethread + Sentence-level edits in a Googledoc. Good.


Thursday, January 30, 2014

Teaching to the Tech

Or teaching in spite of it, really.

Yesterday was our first online class of the semester. I always start with a synchronous online day so that students acclimate to the online environment as quickly as possible. I've been using Adobe Connect for almost a year now. It's not perfect (the layouts aren't malleable; students don't have as many "status indicators" as they do in Wimba and Big Blue Button), but it works. That's what I care about the most: it works.

What didn't work yesterday? Our power. The power went out about an hour and a half before classes started. I had set the opening slide up in Adobe Connect and written out the lesson plan in excruciating detail for my TAs, but I hadn't set up the group Googledocs for the first class, which I had wanted to do because my TA for the first class, S, is new. No power = no internet.

Crap.

O looked outside and reported that the whole block was down. We've only lost power here once--also about an hour before a synchronous online day--and it had come back fairly quickly. But still. Did I want to go into work with O? Set up in his office? No...I had too much prep work to do still. I'd lose half an hour just getting to his office and setting up--that wouldn't work. I'd be incredibly flustered.

"If only I'd replaced my phone by now...I'd have 4G," I said ruefully. I can get a new iPhone for free--I just haven't gotten around to it yet.

"How charged is your phone? You could try hotspot, though I don't know if you'll have enough battery power for five hours. Well, wait, hold on..."

Bingo. Within fifteen minutes, I was back online through Bluetooth and was charging both my phone and my laptop on a car battery that O just so happens to have around. Partners with skills = win.

The power came back on at 9:28, but by then I was already in the classroom and didn't want to risk getting disconnected while switching over to the wireless. I ended up teaching all three classes on the Bluetooth connection. Students reported that my voice would break up a little bit, but not so much that they couldn't understand me. They spent half the class working in groups in Googledocs anyway, so my voice wasn't necessary the whole time.

About those Googledocs? S set them all up successfully without me prompting her. She rocks! Reason #87 to work with former students--S knew exactly what it looked like to work in Gdocs on an online day--she was my student just two semesters ago. She knew what needed to be done and just did it. Plus, my ridiculously detailed lesson plan helped all of us. It was like four pages long, complete with color-coded, italicized cues: TA pastes prompt into demo Googledoc... TA and Lyra model working in Gdocs, making margin comments, using the chat feature...

It totally worked. The detailed LP helped all of us (my TAs and me), and demoing Gdocs live was super easy and, I think, helpful. In the past, I've made a short video on how to use Gdocs, but really--who watches my video tutorials? From what I can tell, no one. Yesterday was much better because within 90 seconds, students watched me create and work in a Gdoc with my TA. That's all they needed. Plus, of course, at least half of my students are experienced Gdoc users, so they could lead the others if necessary.

As for the group activity: I kept it super simple. First, I used the Reading Guide to ask a couple of questions to the class while we were all still in Adobe Connect. "Okay, if your first name begins with a letter between A and M, please answer the following in the chat box: did Summary #1 give you a solid sense of who Gabriel is? Why he wrote this? Where it was published? What his purpose is? .... Everyone else: you're on deck with the same question for Summary #2."

Once we'd done that warm up in AdobeConnect, students hopped over to their Googledocs, where we had pasted in one of the two summaries and a prompt. The prompt asked them to evaluate how well the summary articulated the rhetorical context and main message of the original article. Then, students had to summarize Gabriel in just one sentence. Finally, students had to explain in a couple of sentences why their one-sentence summary was more effective than the sample paragraph summary.

I had allotted ten minutes for this; it was really more like 15-20. That was fine; I still had enough time to paste a couple of the one-sentence versions into the whiteboard in AdobeConnect and touch on strong active verbs. I then said that we'd finish this up on Monday. I need to show all six sentences from all six groups so that students see their work being discussed (I haven't always been good about this--in fact, I'm usually awful about group work follow up, which is bad).

In my last class, right after wrapping up the one-sentence summary analysis and right before showing them the homework and ending class, I asked all students to type one main "takeaway" from today's class: "Type one thing that you learned today--one thing that I emphasized as clearly important." That was awesome, and I plan on doing that in every AdobeConnect class from here on out. And it makes so much sense! It's a chance for every student to do something visibly before leaving class. And it's an example of an effective reinforcement tactic I can do online and can't do face-to-face. I can hardly ask all 19 students to shout out something simultaneously in person--but they can certainly all write and post in the chat box at the same time. Win.

Monday, we'll pick up with those sentences, then I'll talk about Aims/ Methods/ Materials, and then students will write a group summary of their assigned article in about thirty minutes, which will theoretically be possible because I've given them an obscenely through preparation activity to bring into class (a does/ says analysis). Finally--and this is what I'm wicked excited about--once students have completed their paragraph summaries, each student in the group will write a one-sentence version of their own summary with a specified sentence structure: Each member of the group (3 or 4) has to choose a different opening for their one-sentence summary:

  1. "In the..."
  2. "Writing for..."
  3. "In his..."
  4. "Trip Gabriel..."
So excited! This gives us an opportunity to talk about grammar in a fun, practical way: grammar is about choices and effects. Here, the one-sentence summary requires them to shove a lot of content into one sentence (rhetorical context and thesis statement), which can be tricky. Students make grammatical mistakes on this a lot--these are the sentences that start out one way and end another way, as though they've forgotten the structure in which they began. This simple activity will show them a) why this sentence is hard, grammatically, and b) how they can play around with sentence structure to make it all work. I can, time permitting, get in prepositional phrases and end focus. Adjectivals and adverbials will need to wait for another day--which is best, because we will have hit cognitive overload by now.

Did I mention how excited I am about this? So excited! Fly-by grammar that is tethered to an actual activity that only takes 3-4 minutes to complete and has an obvious practical application.

Stay tuned for Tuesday's report on how this worked!